The Washington Humane Society's Humane Law Enforcement
program investigated over 1900 cases of cruelty and neglect last
year, everything from dogs on chains to children torturing cats
to animals shot and killed. A few of these cases are described below.
Poochie as he looked
when he first came to WHS
Poochie as he looked shortly
before leaving for his new home.
Poochie was surrendered to the D.C. Animal Shelter
in March of 2005 by a woman who claimed that he was sick. She told
the Animal Control Officer who picked him up that Poochie, a young
male Pug, had been throwing up every day since Christmas. She said
she did not take him to a veterinarian during the this time but
had decided to give him up instead. The Animal Control Officer who
picked him up immediately contacted Humane Officer Schindler who,
upon seeing how emaciated Poochie was, took custody of him and rushed
him to the veterinarian. At the vet Poochie was found to weigh only
9lbs. and when fed ate ravenously. No one could remember ever having
seen a Pug as skinny as Poochie. Poochie stayed at the veterinarian's
for a few days and did not show any signs of illness. Instead, after
two weeks of proper feeding, Poochie doubled his weight and began
to look like a true Pug. As he gained weight, he gained energy and
soon was happily bouncing off the walls. His new family reports
that he is doing great. The case against his former owner is under
investigation.
Sheba died of heatstroke
after being chained with little access to shade
In July of 2004 an urgent call came in to the Washington
Humane Society about a dog who was left in the backyard in the sun
and "looked half dead." The temperature outside was 87
degrees and Humane Officer Rausch knew that this was a critical
situation. She rushed to the address but when she arrived she found
a devastating scene. Sheba, a female English bulldog, was dead.
She had been chained in the yard and had crawled between two fences
in an attempt to reach shade. A neighbor spoke with HO Rausch and
told her that the dog had been chained out all day and had been
panting heavily and had no water. The yard had no shade at all during
the midday and only a small amount of shade on the edge between
the fences by the afternoon. Sheba's body was removed and sent for
a necropsy. Results came back that Sheba had died from heatstroke.
An arrest warrant was issued for the owner of the dog for violating
the 2001 law prohibiting cruel chaining in the District of Columbia.
The law reads, in part, that an animal may not be tethered in such
a way that does not permit the animal access to food, water, shade,
dry ground, or shelter; or does not permit the animal to escape
harm. Sheba was chained in the direct sun and could not escape the
heat. Sheba's owner had been advised previously not to chain his
dog after another dog of his, also chained in the backyard, became
entangled and injured his leg.
In March of 2005 Sheba's owner Pled guilty
to Cruelty to Animals- Sentencing is pending.
Sandy had a deep
wound where the harness was imbedded in her flesh
Sandy with her new family
In January of 2004, a woman called WHS after her
dog was dropped off by her ex-husband with a harness imbedded into
her flesh. The woman said that she had given Sandy, a seven month
old lab mix, to her husband in August of 2003. She said that Sandy
had still been a small puppy and she had put a pink harness on her.
She said she was horrified when her ex-husband brought the dog back
to find Sandy still wearing the same small harness because Sandy
had grown considerably. The harness was now too small and had cut
into Sandy's flesh. Humane officer A. Parascandola took Sandy to
the veterinarian where the wound was cleaned and treated. Sandy
was also found to have a luxating patella, a genetic condition which
caused Sandy to limp. In the end, Sandy's owner surrendered her
to WHS and, after healing from her wounds and having the luxating
patella surgically corrected, she found a new home. Sandy was adopted
by local author George Pelecanos whose recent book "Drama City"
features a main character who is a Humane Officer with WHS.
In the end two people were charged with
Cruelty to Animals in Sandy's case- the ex-husband and a woman whom
the ex-husband gave Sandy to. The case went to trial and both were
acquitted of Cruelty to Animals but were admonished by the judge
for failing to care for her properly.
Sugar and her friends
where HO M. Battle found them living
Sugar and one of her new friends
in WHS' Director of Humane Law Enforcement's home
In the fall of 2003 HO M. Battle was checking on some dogs when he
drove by an address in NW DC and noticed these four dogs in a small
pen filled with feces and flies. He recognized the dogs from a previous
address where he had seen them. All of the dogs were very underweight
and one old Dachshund/Chihuahua Mix named "Sugar" had one
eye which was dried up and covered with dirt and debris. HO M. Battle
went to the door and met with the owner who stated she had just come
into town that week. She said her kids and her brother were staying
at the house and caring for the dogs. HO M. Battle then spoke to the
owner's 21 year old son who said he had run out of food a week ago
and had called his uncle about the situation but his uncle never brought
the food. The four dogs were impounded and in the next two weeks all
gained weight at the shelter. Initially the owner contacted WHS about
getting the dogs back. During the course of the investigation, it
was discovered that the owner had a history of neglecting animals
in another state. In the end, the four dogs were not returned to the
owner and all were adopted out. During their stay at the shelter Sugar
stole the heart of WHS' Director of Humane Law Enforcement A. Parascandola.
He took her to a veterinarian who said that the eleven year old Sugar
would not regain vision in her bad eye due to the length of the time
that the condition was left untreated. She also had several mammary
tumors and much of her fur was missing due to a skin condition. After
surgery to remove her tumors and to spay her, Sugar went home with
Director of HLE A. Parascandola. She is now happily putting on the
pounds, has a thick, full coat of fur and is acting ten years younger
than her age.
This dog was found
chained to a pole and shot to death
In August of this year WHS investigated the case of a dog shot to
death with a shotgun. The events that unfolded during the investigation
demonstrate how those who commit violence against animals don't stop
there. Often they commit acts of violence against people and are sometimes
victims of violence themselves. In this case, WHS Humane Officer Battle
received a gruesome call from the Metropolitan Police Department.
Responding to calls of shots fired on 24th St. NE a Police Officer
discovered a dog who had been shot and killed. Humane Officer Battle
responded and took photos of the dog. The police stated there was
a witness but the witness was afraid to come outside and identify
the shooter. The witness only gave them the cryptic message that the
shooter was a part of a small group of onlookers watching the police
activity. With no suspect identified, WHS posted a $5000 reward for
information leading to the arrest and conviction of the shooter. While
posting flyers in the area WHS Humane Officer Hart was contacted by
a witness who stated that the shotgun used in the shooting was kept
in an abandoned vehicle on a nearby street. She went to the site and
found police on the scene already with the shotgun in hand. The shotgun
was sent to the crime lab. Information followed quickly in the next
few days and several informants identified the shooter and came forward
as witnesses. No one could provide an explanation for why the suspect,
a 19 year old man, shot the dog. He allegedly told the owner of the
dog that he "had something for the dog" and then shot the
dog. But a troubled picture of the young man was constructed by witnesses.
They all claimed he was known as a troublemaker and one witnesses
claimed he had shot cats in the rear of the building some weeks before.
He was known to keep many guns in his possession and allegedly routinely
robbed and terrorized neighborhood citizens. WHS quickly obtained
an arrest warrant for Felony Cruelty to Animals for the man and attempted
to locate him. Witnesses stated that he had been seen packing a bag
and fleeing the area. Three days later the man was arrested for stealing
from a car and was suspected of setting two cars on fire and attempting
to set an apartment building on fire. He was arraigned for the Cruelty
to Animals charge at this time. Two days after this arrest the man
himself was shot and killed in the early morning hours. Five informants
subsequently split the $5000 reward, receiving $1000 a piece for the
information they provided to WHS during the investigation of the dog's
shooting. Without being able to offer a reward it is possible no one
would have come forward. The reward money is taken from WHS's Fugitive
Fund and is supported through donations.
This was the sight
that greeted Humane Officers
once the front door was opened
One of the 44 Dogs removed
from the address
In May of this year, a police officer was driving
down a street in NE when he was flagged down by a citizen. The citizen
pointed out a house on the block which she claimed housed a large
number of dogs. She said no one lived at the address and the owners
were only seen coming once a week. She said there was a strong odor
of urine and feces from the house and the area was infested with
flies. The police officer called the Washington Humane Society and
Humane Officer Hart responded. When she arrived Officer Hart immediately
noticed a strong stench coming from the house. She could hear many
dogs inside but the windows were covered in plastic and difficult
to see into. She posted a notice on the door for the owners to contact
her. Over the next week she made numerous attempts to catch up with
the owners at the address but to no avail. Because the health and
safety of the dogs at the address was in question Officer Hart moved
quickly to obtain a search warrant for the address. When WHS Officers
entered the premises they found 44 dogs living in the house. The
dogs were blocked into separate rooms of the house and the floors
were covered with fecal matter. There was no running water in the
house and only one room had water available for the dogs. The were
several day old puppies along with adults and three month old puppies.
Many of the dogs were extremely underweight. Removing the dogs was
a slow process as many of them appeared to have never been outside
the house and were very frightened. The owners were later found
to be living in an apartment nearby where they were keeping three
additional dogs. They surrendered all forty four dogs to the Washington
Humane Society. Several of the dogs were later adopted into homes
where they have done well after a period of adjustment.
On December 02, 2003 the owner of these
dogs plead guilty in DC Superior Court to two charges of misdemeanor
animal cruelty. Sentencing is pending.
Veterinarian's
and staff work to save Reds' life
Reds' wounds
After a concerted effort from the Washington Humane
Society, with the assistance of the City Council and the United
States Attorney's Office, Washington DC passed a Felony Animal Cruelty
Law in June of 2001. The first person charged under the law pled
guilty in June of 2002. The case began in April of 2002 when the
Metropolitan Police Department called WHS to the scene of a domestic
dispute. Humane Officer A. Parascandola responded to the address.
When he arrived he found Reds, a ten year old male Pit Bull, bleeding
heavily from two puncture wounds along the left side of his chest.
A woman at the address said that she was the owner of Reds. She
said that she had been arguing with her husband and he had pulled
a knife on her and threatened her. She said that Reds entered the
room and began to bark at her husband who turned and stabbed the
dog. She also said that her husband had cut the dog before, during
a similar incident, and the dog's injuries had required several
stitches. Officer Parascandola transported Reds to a veterinarian
who attempted to stabilize him. Despite the efforts of everyone
at the veterinary clinic Reds died the next day from his injuries.
The owner was very distraught by the death of her dog and stated
that he had protected her for ten years.
WHS then obtained an arrest warrant for the owner's
husband for Cruelty to Animals, while the Metropolitan Police Department
obtained their own arrest warrant for weapons and assault charges.
In June 2002, the owner's husband pled guilty to one count of Felony
Animal Cruelty, one count Simple Assault, and one count Possession
of a Prohibited Weapon. He was sentenced to two years in prison
for the Cruelty to Animals charge and 90 days for each of the other
two charges, to run concurrent with the Animal Cruelty sentence.
Before the felony law passed the maximum sentence for Animal Cruelty
was six months in jail and/or a $250.00 fine.
This
bird was denied veterinary care for two weeks after being
returned to a major pet store with severed feet
and severely clipped wing and tail feathers.
The Washington Humane Society received a complaint
from a citizen about an injured bird who was languishing without
proper care in a cage at a major pet store in DC. Humane Officer
Boozer responded to the store and found an injured bird whose feet
were bloody stumps and whose wings and tail had been severely clipped.
The employees told Officer Boozer that the bird had been returned
the day before in that condition by a customer who claimed the bird
had been attacked by a larger bird who shared his cage. Officer
Boozer spoke with the Corporate Manager who said that the bird had
been taken to a vet. Officer Boozer made several attempts to verify
the bird had been vetted before discovering the bird had not been
taken to a veterinarian but had, in fact, been "adopted"
by an employee. The employee who "adopted" the bird said
that the Corporate Manager told her to take the bird home. Officer
Boozer promptly called the Regional Manager who said he was familiar
with the situation and would call to make sure the bird was vetted.
Finally, two weeks after arriving at the store with his feet severed,
the bird was taken to the veterinarian. The veterinarian recommenced
euthanasia and the bird was euthanised.
WHS also tried to find the original owner of the
bird, who had caused the injuries, but store records turned out
to be inaccurate and the purchaser was not found. WHS had been especially
eager to find this person because when she returned the mangled
bird, store employees sold her another bird.
An arrest warrant was issued for the Corporate
Manager for failure to provide the bird with proper veterinary care.
These
dogs were two of the five removed from the address
On February 17, 2002, the Washington Humane Society
received a report of pit bulls fighting in the woods. Humane Officer
Parascandola arrived on the scene and saw a man enter the woods
along a dirt path. The officer followed the man, and came to a gully.
Looking down into the bottom of the gully, Officer Parascandola
could see and hear pit bulls fighting inside a makeshift ring made
of boards propped together. There were several spectators present.
The officer called for police assistance, and while he waited for
them to arrive he saw four men exit the woods with a pit bull and
leave in two vehicles.
The Washington Humane Society was able to trace
the license plates on one of the vehicles, and on March 3, 2002,
WHS obtained and executed a search warrant for a home in Northeast.
Officer Parascandola identified the man who resided at the home
as one of the men present at the pit bull fight. Five pit bulls
were removed from the address and were examined by a veterinarian
and found to be suffering from mange and infected ears. One dog,
a female, had infected gums, her mouth was riddled with ulcers,
and her temperature was elevated. She had numerous scars on her
front legs and neck. A third pit bull had open sores and skin lesions.
One pit bull had a large 2 millimeter thick scar on her neck, numerous
old scars on her head, and a skin infection. The fifth pit bull
suffered from a skin infection, and had numerous old scars on her
muzzle, head, and forelimbs, consistent with wounds from dog bites
and scratches.
The owner was arrested on May 1, 2002 for dog fighting,
a felony offense punishable by up to 5 years in prison and up to
$25,000, or both, and failure to provide veterinary care, which
carries a maximum sentence of 6 months in prison or a $250 fine,
or both. He pleaded guilty to being present at a dog fight, a misdemeanor,
and was sentenced to 45 days in jail suspended, 18 months probation,
and was ordered to own no animals for the probation period. He was
also given 40 hours of community service, and ordered to reimburse
veterinary fees to WHS and to pay court costs.
Earthquake,
emaciated and suffering from a severe skin condition
The area where Earthquake was
forced to live
On September 25, 2001 the Washington Humane Society
received a complaint about a thin pit bull chained to a tree. Humane
Officer Parascandola responded, and met with a man who claimed ownership
of the dog and showed him "Earthquake", an adult male
pit bull, who was extremely underweight, his ribs, backbone, and
pelvic bones all clearly visible. The dog also suffered from a skin
condition -- the majority of the dog's body was raw and oozing blood.
The owner stated that the dog had not been taken to a veterinarian.
Earthquake was impounded and transported to a veterinarian, who
found the dog in emaciated condition, weighing only 17.6 lbs, and
when offered food the dog ate ravenously. Additionally, the dog
was found to be suffering from a severe skin condition. The affected
areas of the skin were bleeding, dripping blood onto the floor whenever
touched. The vet estimated the severe condition had been present
for at least two weeks. After being held at WHS for a few weeks
and receiving food, medicine, and love Earthquake gained weight
and his skin cleared up.
Earthquake's owner was arrested on April 12, 2002,
for failing to provide food and veterinary care for Earthquake.
He was found guilty and was sentenced to 180 days in jail with 90
days suspended, 2 years of probation, and was ordered to not own
animals for that period.
This
man is being placed under arrest by Metro Police for assaulting
these two dogs.
On February 19, 2002, WHS received a report of a man beating two
Akitas with a stick. When WHS Humane Officers Parascandola and Battle
arrived, Metropolitan Police officers were already on the scene,
and had the man in custody. The man told the officers that the dogs
belonged to a neighbor, and that he had been walking them without
leashes, when the dogs ran into traffic. He admitted that he had
beaten the dogs with a broomstick until it broke in two pieces.
The witness said that the man had beat the dogs with a broomstick
until it broke in two, then he continued beating them with the two
broken pieces, one in each hand. The witness said that the beating
had continued for 20 minutes. The two dogs were both moving as if
they were bruised and sore, and one of the dogs was limping. The
man was arrested, and the dogs were impounded and examined by a
veterinarian. Amazingly, the dogs sustained no major injuries, only
mild abrasions, and were later returned to their rightful owner.
On June 6, 2002 before D.C. Superior Court Judge
Z. Mitchell-Rankin, the man was sentenced to 180 days in jail, with
all but 30 days suspended. He was to serve the 30 days in a work
release program. He was also given two years of probation during
which he may not have contact with any animals.
This
rottweiler and pit bull died in the backyard.
And this man was arrested for
it.
On December 10, 2001, the DC Animal Control Agency
(DCAC) received a call from a man asking for assistance with his
two dogs, which he believed were dying. An animal control officer
responded to the call and found two dogs, an adult male pit bull
and an adult female rottweiler, dead in the back yard. The officer
contacted the Washington Humane Society and turned the case over
to Humane Officer Battle. The pit bull was found attached to a post
by a chain and was emaciated. The second dog was lying halfway out
of a doghouse. The yard was filthy with fecal matter, both old and
new, and the yard smelled strongly of feces and urine. There was
no food present, and the only water available was filthy with dirt
and other debris. The owner of the pit bull and said his mother
owned the rottweiler. He said he fed both dogs most of the time
and his mom fed the dogs some of the time. He said he noticed the
pit bull's appetite had changed two weeks previously and noticed
he lost weight the week before. He said he had noticed that the
pit bull limped. When asked if he took the dogs to a veterinarian
he said he had not, and he said that he thought the dogs were poisoned.
The veterinarian's report showed that the pit bull
was profoundly emaciated, with no body fat present whatsoever, and
there was no food found in the dog's stomach or intestines. It was
concluded that the cause of death for the pit bull was a direct
result of starvation. The veterinarian reported that the rottweiler
died of hypotensive shock, caused by gastric torsion.
The owner was arrested on February 13, 2002 and
was found guilty in DC Superior Court for starvation of the pit
bull. He was acquitted on the other charge of starving the rottweiler.
He was sentenced to 180 days in jail, all suspended, one year probation,
drug testing/treatment, mental health counseling, and court costs.